Bethany has been playing or coaching volleyball for the last 14 years, and this past fall was the Freshman Coach at Carmel High School. This is her first year coaching at Team Indiana.

Bethany graduated from Carmel High School in 2005, where she earned four varsity letters in volleyball. Her senior year she was named a First Team All-State player, an All-Conference pick in the MIC, and was a member of the Indiana South All-Star Team. She was also on the All-Tournament Team at the 2005 USA Volleyball Junior Olympic 18 Open Championships while finishing in second place with the Munciana Samurai.

Bethany then played for four years at the University of Dayton as a middle blocker, earning All-Conference Honors her junior and senior years. She was chosen as the team MVP her senior year. Through her four years at UD the Flyers made three NCAA appearances. She graduated with a degree in Early Childhood Education.